2000FUN論壇

標題: ROUTER三選一 [打印本頁]

作者: civiclau 時間: 11-10-4 04:55 PM 標題: ROUTER三選一

因小弟近日轉左用200M上網(遲D會再上用1G),而家中既ROUTER(WZR-HP-G300NH)因未能食得晒,所以一定要轉ROUTER,而小弟諗住買哩3款ROUTER其中一隻,希望大家能及一點意見及講一吓優或缺點!!
同時又有否其他ROUTER好推介,同時估計張推出既 ASUS華碩 (RT-N66U)又如何呢??

用途:打機 BT 上網....睇片等等~

作者: lawsc01 時間: 11-10-4 07:40 PM

其實上網 200mb 已經夠用唔曬tim

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-5 09:46 AM

用途?
只係上網同埋係剩LAN要200M的話
連TP-LINK 180蚊貨仔都搞得掂

作者: civiclau 時間: 11-10-5 07:52 PM

本帖最後由 civiclau 於 11-10-5 07:53 PM 編輯

Qoo記發表於 11-10-5 09:46 AM
用途?
只係上網同埋係剩LAN要200M的話
連TP-LINK 180蚊貨仔都搞得掂

首先因打機,所以一定要穩定,但又要BT....所以要用高級一點,因為有好多ROUTER今本連200M都食唔晒,好似我個G300NH,200M輸出只有14X左右(WAN TO LAN)

作者: D@niel_Ng 時間: 11-10-5 11:34 PM

Throughput參考....

http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/lanwan/router-charts/view

作者: D@niel_Ng 時間: 11-10-5 11:36 PM

Throughput參考....

http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/lanwan/router-charts/view

作者: 天地無雙 時間: 11-10-6 12:31 AM

本帖最後由天地無雙於 11-10-6 12:31 AM 編輯

Qoo記發表於 11-10-5 09:46 AM
用途?
只係上網同埋係剩LAN要200M的話
連TP-LINK 180蚊貨仔都搞得掂

咁又未必，100Mb還可以，高過100Mb有時都唔係好得
TP-Link 1043 200Mb 陳豪Plan D人都話唔多掂

作者: D@niel_Ng 時間: 11-10-6 12:38 AM

天地無雙發表於 11-10-6 12:31 AM
咁又未必，100Mb還可以，高過100Mb有時都唔係好得
TP-Link 1043 200Mb 陳豪Plan D人都話唔多掂 ...

就係Throughput唔夠......

作者: civiclau 時間: 11-10-6 06:58 PM

現在諗緊draytek Vigor2130n / linksys e4200 邊隻好....同埋年尾又出RT-N66U

作者: 天地無雙 時間: 11-10-6 07:50 PM

civiclau 發表於 11-10-6 06:58 PM
現在諗緊draytek Vigor2130n / linksys e4200 邊隻好....同埋年尾又出RT-N66U

E4200 / 2130n EPC果邊都有好多討論，不妨參考下

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-6 09:27 PM

係到請教咁多位C HING
都頭痕左好耐
首先我做FTP俾人DOWN野
行大約~8-9MB/S傳左十GB 8GB就有機會斷LAN
(右下角個LAN變左黃色感嘆號)
BT連接數一多或者速度快耐左又係咁
次次都要重機先冇事

作者: D@niel_Ng 時間: 11-10-7 02:00 AM

Qoo記發表於 11-10-6 09:27 PM
係到請教咁多位C HING
都頭痕左好耐
首先我做FTP俾人DOWN野

有機會ROUTER過熱........

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-7 05:35 PM

回復 D@niel_Ng 的帖子

者係冇解了
平野果然係平野

作者: ★犬夜叉★ 時間: 11-10-8 09:00 AM

有300N+ 好多都OK-.-

作者: D@niel_Ng 時間: 11-10-8 12:17 PM

★犬夜叉★ 發表於 11-10-8 09:00 AM
有300N+ 好多都OK-.-

300N+同樓主所問無乜關係!

作者: R3 時間: 11-10-8 04:36 PM

Qoo記發表於 11-10-7 05:35 PM
回復 D@niel_Ng 的帖子

者係冇解了

斷估你唔係講緊TP-Link 既WR841ND掛??

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-8 06:54 PM

回復 R3 的帖子

lee個價位仲有第2部?

作者: R3 時間: 11-10-8 07:14 PM

Qoo記發表於 11-10-8 06:54 PM
回復 R3 的帖子

lee個價位仲有第2部?

可能我好彩...暫時未有事

作者: civiclau 時間: 11-10-10 10:26 AM

有左決定了,決定入手2130N

作者: 雲路 時間: 11-10-10 11:37 AM

civiclau 發表於 11-10-5 07:52 PM
首先因打機,所以一定要穩定,但又要BT....所以要用高級一點,因為有好多ROUTER今本連200M都食唔晒,好似我個 ...

我打機一台機；BT / EMULE 一台機
幾年前開始用D-LINK 655
如果唔係供應商既問題,基本上幾星期都不會斷線

作者: 雲路 時間: 11-10-10 11:44 AM

civiclau 發表於 11-10-10 10:26 AM
有左決定了,決定入手2130N

呢台 ?

作者: civiclau 時間: 11-10-10 03:58 PM

雲路發表於 11-10-10 11:44 AM
呢台 ?

係呀!因有人用哩部去test pccx 500m出黎有成48xm 食足500m,而且哩個牌子本身都好穩定,所以決定帶佢回家

作者: 雲路 時間: 11-10-10 05:22 PM

civiclau 發表於 11-10-10 03:58 PM
係呀!因有人用哩部去test pccx 500m出黎有成48xm 食足500m,而且哩個牌子本身都好穩定,所以決定帶佢回家 ...

睇網評,都話係勁野
可是我鍾情 D-LINK

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-10 05:46 PM

我想脫離做FTP會冇神神斷既日子咋"
都唔知LAN定ROUTER雞

作者: civiclau 時間: 11-10-10 05:49 PM

雲路發表於 11-10-10 05:22 PM
睇網評,都話係勁野
可是我鍾情 D-LINK

咁路SIR,咁你要試吓哩個draytek牌子出既ROUTER了,我問左好多人(包括我做開d電腦代理既朋友),同網上收集到既資料話比我知,draytek本身出開公司用既網絡裝置(其實佢地網都有買埋d野),所以本身穩定性(口碑)係唔錯,其實CISCO 都係做開公司用既網絡裝置,穩定性(口碑)一樣係好高(比draytek重高),但RV220W 真係好貴要$23XX,同埋只有英文介面(對於不懂英文既我比較失望),至於同linksys 合作既E4200,做左TEST出黎唔知點解連200M都冇,哩個真係幾失敗吓

(我唔係好明哩個smallnetbuilder網會TEST到有咁高分數),所以綜合穩定性,速度及價錢,性價比2130n係最高,而都係我多日來再各大網站(包括埋呢度)所收集到既最終結果

作者: D@niel_Ng 時間: 11-10-11 03:07 AM

回復 civiclau 的帖子

其實有無諗過砌1台pc router呢？

作者: civiclau 時間: 11-10-11 05:40 AM

本帖最後由 civiclau 於 11-10-11 06:47 AM 編輯

D@niel_Ng 發表於 11-10-11 03:07 AM
回復 civiclau 的帖子

其實有無諗過砌1台pc router呢？

咁我又真冇諗過(未聽過),師兄所說不會是一部PC兩張Lan卡吧?小弟願聞其詳

作者: 雲路 時間: 11-10-12 11:29 AM

civiclau 發表於 11-10-10 05:49 PM
咁路SIR,咁你要試吓哩個draytek牌子出既ROUTER了,我問左好多人(包括我做開d電腦代理既朋友),同網上收集到 ...

一分錢一分貨

DrayTek Vigor 2130 Gigabit Wan Router (3G+Giga 雙寬頻高速路由器) HK$ 1580
(好似打小左個N)

我兩個D-LINK 655 既價錢

將來我如轉用BB1000,我會買你呢個

作者: D@niel_Ng 時間: 11-10-12 12:59 PM

civiclau 發表於 11-10-11 05:40 AM
咁我又真冇諗過(未聽過),師兄所說不會是一部PC兩張Lan卡吧?小弟願聞其詳 ...

係....可用ATOM+張CF卡+DUAL LAN+1G RAM效能上已大大超越普通ROUTER

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-12 06:16 PM

雲路發表於 11-10-12 11:29 AM
一分錢一分貨

DrayTek Vigor 2130 Gigabit Wan Router (3G+Giga 雙寬頻高速路由器) HK$ 1580

開頭見到TP-LINK咁平又幾好用
仲以為唔洗用多錢先換到效能
點知都係一分錢一分貨"

作者: civiclau 時間: 11-10-12 06:51 PM

雲路發表於 11-10-12 11:29 AM
一分錢一分貨

DrayTek Vigor 2130 Gigabit Wan Router (3G+Giga 雙寬頻高速路由器) HK$ 1580

N有無線WIFI,VN可以玩埋VOIP

作者: 雲路 時間: 11-10-12 07:32 PM

civiclau 發表於 11-10-12 06:51 PM
N有無線WIFI,VN可以玩埋VOIP

那你買左幾多 ? .?
我出年轉BB1000 可能會買佢
當然我希望D-LINK 都會出新機啦

作者: civiclau 時間: 11-10-12 07:54 PM

雲路發表於 11-10-12 07:32 PM
那你買左幾多 ? .?
我出年轉BB1000 可能會買佢
當然我希望D-LINK 都會出新機啦 ...

$17XX

其實....有冇須要用到1000M咁大??因為出海都只係20M,同埋好多時都要睇人地比唔比到你

作者: 雲路 時間: 11-10-12 10:13 PM

civiclau 發表於 11-10-12 07:54 PM
$17XX
其實....有冇須要用到1000M咁大??因為出海都只係20M,同埋好多時都要睇人地比唔比到你:donno ...

100m / $109月
1000m / $200月
大約係咁上下
試下新野俾籍口自己買新router
我覺d-link 太好用,用左3年乜事都冇
分分鐘用到6,7 年

作者: fatau 時間: 11-10-26 04:52 PM

本帖最後由 fatau 於 11-10-26 04:53 PM 編輯

我2010年頭用2130n到前排轉左rv220w

可以話...rv220w bugs多到嘔
八月份出o既firmware入面 known issue
http://www.cisco.com/en/US/docs/ ... e_Notes_1.0.2.4.pdf

Date Revision
Oct. 13, 2011 Added a known issue: The number of QuickVPN Client users
supported is limited to 10 instead of 25

Known Issues in Version 1.0.2.4
• The number of QuickVPN Client users supported is limited to 10 instead of
25.4 Release Notes for RV220W Firmware Version 1.0.2.4
Release Notes
• A 6to4 tunnel may encounter packet loss depending on the type of NIC
used.
• When Internet Explorer version 9 is used, the Status > View Logs page does
not include line breaks between system log entries.
Work Around: Use Firefox or Chrome to launch the Configuration Utility.
• On the Administration > Firmware Upgrade page, the Firmware Last
Updated field is blank.
• SSL VPN is not working for users whose computers are running Windows 7
64-bit.
Work Around: Use Windows XP 64-bit or Windows 7 32-bit.
• If a client has its IP address bound to a MAC address in the IP/MAC Binding
table, firewall rules/filters enabled for the client no longer work. All traffic is
allowed to pass through this client even though IP blocking/filtering for the
client is enabled on the RV220W.
Work Around: Do not use IP/MAC Binding for a client that has firewall rules/
filters assigned to it.
• The following GUI configurations require restarting the RV220W:
- Changing the time zone to use an NTP server.
- Manually setting the time.
- Enabling and configuring remote management.
• The online help file for Wi-Fi Multimedia (WMM) should read “WMM: Opens
the QoS Configuration page to edit the QoS configuration parameters for
this profile.”
• SNMP MIBs only support Read access.
• VPN connectivity can be lost when using SSL VPN port forwarding and
later versions of Firefox.
Work Around: Use Internet Explorer or Firefox version 3.6.17.
• WLAN clients fail to connect to the router using WPA Enterprise or
WPA2 Enterprise.
Work Around: To work around this issue, disable the Block Fragmentation
option in the Firewall page.
• Known open issue with enabling the Aggressive mode for IPSec VPN.
Work Around: Use the Main mode instead.
• The DHCP Client Table does not show all clients. Release Notes for RV220W Firmware Version 1.0.2.4 5
Release Notes
• NTP stops working after upgrading from firmware version 1.0.1.0 to 1.0.2.4.
Work Around: Factory reset the router.
• Certain Syslogs such as IKE and Kernel logs will be shown with the time
stamp of 2000-01-01 and not the current time.
• The Syslog does not always list the timestamp in sequential order.
• The router fails to apply trusted or self-signed SSL certificates to HTTPS
sessions. Although on-screen messages indicate that the certificate was
successfully added, the router uses the original default certificate for
subsequent HTTPS connections.
Work Around: The router will use a certificate that is signed by root CA. You
can generate a Self Certificate Request from the router and have it signed
by the root CA. Upload the root CA certificate in the Trusted CA Certificate
table. Finally, upload the signed certificate in the Active Self Certificate
table. See the Security > SSL Certificate page.
• Internet NAT redirection does not work using firewall port-forwarding rules.
A LAN client cannot access a service by using the WAN IP address of the
LAN device (such as an IP camera or an FTP server).
Work Around: Do not use the Firewall > Port Forwarding page, but instead
create the forwarding rule by using the Firewall > Access Rules page. The
working port forwarding entry is created along with the firewall access rule.
• A critical error is encountered when attempting to configure settings for
remote logging to a syslog server.
Work Around: Enable email logging on the Administration > Logging >
Remote Logging Configuration page.
• A client cannot connect via SSLVPN with a corporate proxy setting.
Work Around: Disable the proxy setting or set the proxy using the IP
address instead of the domain name. For example, in Internet Explorer,
adjust the proxy settings by going to Tools > Internet Options. Click the
Connections tab, and then click the LAN settings button. Proceed as
needed:
- To disable the proxy, uncheck the Use a proxy server box and then
check the Automatically detect settings box. Click OK to save the
changes, and then click OK to close the Internet Options window.
OR
- To identify the proxy by IP address: Check the Use a proxy server
box, delete the domain name if in use, and enter the IP address of the
proxy server in the Address box. 6 Release Notes for RV220W Firmware Version 1.0.2.4
Release Notes
• There are issues with the SSL VPN client installer on Internet Explorer 8.
Work Around: Adjust the settings in Internet Explorer as described below.
1. In Internet Explorer, go to Tools > Internet Options.
2. Click the Security tab, and then click the Custom Level button.
3. Scroll down to ActiveX controls and plug-ins.
4. For Automatic prompting for ActiveX controls, click Enable.
5. For Download signed ActiveX controls, click Enable.
6. Click OK to save the changes, and then click OK to close the Internet
Options window.
• A client cannot connect via SSLVPN when using MacOs+Java 1.6.0.26.
Work Around: Downgrade Java version and use FireFox version 3.16.
Follow the procedure described below to downgrade Java and Firefox.
1. Login to your MacIntosh computer as administrator.
2. Start the terminal: Finder> Applications > Utilities > Terminal.
3. At the command prompt enter these commands:
user1% sudo passwd root
Enter Password:
Changing password for root
New password:
Verify password:
The “root” account is enabled after the above steps.
4. Log out of your current account.
5. Re-login and at the prompt, enter your “root” username and password
that you've just created.Release Notes for RV220W Firmware Version 1.0.2.4 7
Release Notes
6. Check Java version: Finder> Applications > Utilities > Java Preferences.
If Java version is 10.6.0.24 or higher, go here to download and then install
earlier version of Java: http://www.uploadstation.com/file/a44a57U/
JavaforMacOSX10.6Update1Downgrade.zip
If the install is successful, continue to the next step. If your computer
does not allow to install of older Java version, open a Terminal session
(Finder> Applications > Utilities > Terminal) and enter these commands
to bypass checking Java version during installation:
root% cd /System/Library/Frameworks/JavaVM.framework/
Resources
root% mv Info.plist Info.plist.orig
root% mv version.plist version.plist.orig
7. Download FireFox v3.16 for MacOs from this site:
http://www.mozilla.com/en-US/firefox/all-older.html
8. Install the FireFox 3.16. (Enter “root” password if asked)
9. Open the FireFox browser, and log into the router as SSLVPN user. The
portal page appears

作者: civiclau 時間: 11-10-27 06:34 PM

fatau 發表於 11-10-26 04:52 PM
我2010年頭用2130n到前排轉左rv220w

可以話...rv220w bugs多到嘔

有錢仔

邊隻好用D

作者: fatau 時間: 11-10-27 09:05 PM

本帖最後由 fatau 於 11-10-27 09:07 PM 編輯

civiclau 發表於 11-10-27 06:34 PM
有錢仔
邊隻好用D

最後轉左DLINK DSR1000N
RV220W同2130N封印左(如果唔介意二手我都想放左是旦一部

, 不過2130N無左保, 而RV220W用左個幾月)

隻DLINK除左介面功能擺位唔合理(同RV/DRAYTEK比) 穩定性同速度都好好
試左用部NAS 當WAN, FTP 同部PC SEND FILE, >900mbps
仲可能因為NAS同PC只係用普通HDD而慢左
不過係得DRAYTEK先有WOL RV220W同1000N都無

哩點攪到要用QNAP NAS做WOL+ SSH 叫起電腦麻煩左D

如果諗得RV220W 都成$21XX 不如再多幾舊

作者: fatau 時間: 11-10-27 09:21 PM

本帖最後由 fatau 於 11-10-27 09:26 PM 編輯

有D數字參考下
RV220W CN5010 400MHZ 64MB RAM 32MB ROM SINGLE WAN SSL VPN
DSR1000N CN5010 500MHZ 256MB RAM 32MB ROM DUAL WAN + USB 只SUPPORT DWM156 作3G USB MODEM SSL VPN
2130N VSC7501 266MHZ 64MB RAM 8MB ROM SINGLE WAN + USB 可用一般3G USB MODEM官網有LIST (有HNAT, 唔開限制功能約800mbps, 開左得返80左右) 無SSL VPN

穩定性三隻都好, 只係BUGS RV220W嚇親人
比我排 1000N>2130N>>>RV220W
如果唔係2130N 無SSL VPN 係唔會轉ROUTER, 2130N開頭都好BUGS一堆, 不過佢地台灣TS好好, TELNET入部ROUTER幫我改FIREWALL SETTING 比我頂住先, 再改FIRMWARE SEND黎
開頭用DHCP WAN會唔識RENEW而斷線, WII同某DDEVICE用唔到WIFI, FIREWALL 有時失效, VPN斷線...都攪左幾個月先正常之後就好好用
乜牌子都好, 唔好買太新O既MODEL, 唔係好似變左免費測試員咁

額外 NETGEAR SRX5308 CN5010 700MHZ 512MB RAM 有CHING 都話麻麻唔夠1000N好用
無USB 無WIFI
原先我都對DLINK好抗拒, 但比CHING 講左一排又覺得可以一試

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-27 09:46 PM

尋日又學到新野
原來有人幫router做第3方OS
好似好遲先知咁
DDWRT真係幾好用
多好多setting
希望解決到我FTP架站會有機會斷既問題

作者: fatau 時間: 11-10-27 10:01 PM

本帖最後由 fatau 於 11-10-27 10:06 PM 編輯

Qoo記發表於 11-10-27 09:46 PM
尋日又學到新野
原來有人幫router做第3方OS
好似好遲先知咁

DDWRT 有個問題
就係乜ROUTER, 就算用最新最快O既CPU 都係得百幾mbps throughput
原本有HNAT 會廢左
WIFI N方面做得比較差

非BROADCOM CPU 又會差D, 穩定性差DD, 功能少過BROADCOM 類等

進階D用OPENWRT 會仲好, 又會快返同原裝差唔少(一般原裝FIRMWARE會最快)
不過難用難FLASH(同DDWRT比)

作者: 爭霸者 時間: 11-10-29 11:54 PM

第3個la@@

作者: fatau 時間: 11-10-30 01:09 AM

得閒過EPC望下小弟個測試
有頭兩部router

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-30 12:04 PM

回復 fatau 的帖子

DDWRT仲搞緊port forward
唔知點解彈唔入PC

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-30 12:16 PM

回復 fatau 的帖子

有冇link

作者: fatau 時間: 11-10-30 02:02 PM

回復 Qoo記的帖子

好耐無係2000FUN 驚唔出得link

http://www.hkepc.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=1698539

作者: fatau 時間: 11-10-30 02:03 PM

Qoo記發表於 11-10-30 12:04 PM
回復 fatau 的帖子

DDWRT仲搞緊port forward

應該無乜特別野要改...CAP PORT FORWARD O個版出黎睇下

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-31 05:23 PM

回復 fatau 的帖子

lee個好似係某D tp link router通病
port forward會卡住
搞左好耐都唔得
佢對外來連線唔識彈入去
彈回原廠用住先
加上佢時不時斷線
唔用VPN用番原廠算

聽閒DD WRT最岩用係boardcom機

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-31 05:26 PM

師兄加問
正常一部giga lan router
要穩定唔會時不時入唔到主控或斷線
中用量BT
做FTP或不同ser高速傳輸唔會好易斷線
以上要求大約幾錢

作者: Qoo記 時間: 11-10-31 05:29 PM

FTP SER
filezilla server
windows 7 ultimate x64 sp1
>5MB/s傳輸10GB檔左右
外網down好易down到一半斷左連線
有時server side會斷時有時又唔斷
初步估會係咩問題

歡迎光臨 2000FUN論壇 (https://www.2000fun.com/)